There is an ever growing sense that our democratic process is broken, that it's impossible for an average voter to have her voice heard, that no matter how he votes or how loudly he protests the politicians in power are going to take whatever actions they want, the will of the people be damned. This is why voter turnout is so low and why people feel like voting just flat-out doesn't matter. The Republican members of the General Assembly this week seemed hell-bent to show the voters of North Carolina that the impotence of public opinion is not simply a "feeling," it is absolutely a fact. The GOP showed us precisely how broken our democratic process is.
Our General Assembly meets for regular sessions once per year. The "long session" in odd years runs from January-July and the "short session" in even years from April-June. These are the only times that your elected representatives are generally called upon to pass laws. This year, the General Assembly met in 4 special called additional sessions. The last time the general assembly held that many special sessions was 1898 as it moved to cement the passage of Jim Crow Laws, not exactly a proud moment in our state's history and certainly not a time we should seek to emulate now.
Special sessions allow the Legislature to respond to public emergencies, events like the historic flooding in coastal communities following hurricane Matthew in October. The Governor's special called session to pass a disaster relief bill was the ordinary and proper use of that constitutional provision. What happened next was anything but ordinary or proper.
On Wednesday after both houses passed the disaster relief bill, the Republican members of the assembly shocked their Democratic colleagues by adjourning the special session called by the Governor and immediately convening a new special session called by the General Assembly itself. The Democratic members of the assembly were given no notice that the session would be called, or afforded any opportunity to contribute to the formulation of the bills to be drafted and considered. Introducing legislation in a special session called in secret deprives the public of the opportunity to fully vet, understand and respond to new laws. It was a move carefully designed to ensure that as few people as possible would have as little time as possible to understand and comment on the impacts of the new laws.
Over the following 2 days, the Republican's introduced and passed legislation that made drastic changes to state government.
SB 4 completely redesigns the state's election oversight system. It combines the current Ethics Commission and State Board of Elections; changes the composition of the county board of elections in all 100 counties; changes the terms and operations of the Industrial Commission; adds an en banc review procedure to the state Court of Appeals; and makes our appellate court judicial races partisan.
HB 17 strips the State Board of Education of virtually all power to run the state's education system, vesting its previous authority in the newly elected Superintendent of Public Instruction, Mark Johnson. The bill also strips the incoming Governor of nearly 1,100 appointments he would have made to the administrative agencies he oversees. This bill hasn't been signed yet by the Governor and if you are itching to make your fury heard, calling the Governor at (919) 814-2000 and urging him to veto the bill would be an excellent way to do that.
Look, I'm not saying that all of these measures are bad just because they were introduced by Republicans. I'm saying they are bad because they did not follow a process that allows for Democratic representatives to contribute to the formulation of important state policy and they deprived the public of the opportunity to offer meaningful input. It would have been really nice to have had an opportunity to consult with the State Bar about the impacts of changes to the appellate review process, for instance. With super majorities in both houses, Republicans were unwilling to have thoughtful, deliberate discussion about these measures with their Democratic colleagues, simply because they didn't need to. Those Democratic colleagues represent millions of North Carolinians. Refusing to engage or compromise with them essentially tells those 3.5 million North Carolinians that the GOP really doesn't give a rip about their opinions, and that is just wrong.
As the public got word of what was going down in Raleigh, they flooded the General Assembly with thousands of phone calls and emails and they showed up in person to let their representatives know they did not have the support of their constituents. But the response of Republicans on the house floor was to discount the emails by saying the vast majority were from out of state (they weren't), and that protestors didn't deserve to observe the proceedings because they were not being properly decorous. None of the Republican comments responded to the outpouring of citizen opposition. Instead they cleared the chamber and began arresting the public and even the media for trying to be present to make their opposition heard. The protestors were not from out-of-state and they weren't paid to be there. They were North Carolinians who were furious with the heavy-handed governing of a general assembly completely unwilling to engage with them or respond to their concerns. Instead, our state government arrested elderly women, a mother who had her child with her, a combat veteran who served in both Iraq and Afghanistan, a member of the press, and even Santa.
That is why our current democratic process is broken-because our representatives are no longer willing to engage in debate, find common ground, and compromise with one another. They feel no need to respond at all to dissatisfied constituents. In this year's presidential election, North Carolina broke 50% Republican and 46% Democratic. So, despite the fact that the Republican legislature has managed to gerrymander districts to give themselves a 3/4 majority in the legislature, the citizens they represent statewide are practically evenly divided between conservative and liberal ideologies. We are a moderate state and our elected representatives should represent that moderate make-up in drafting, introducing and considering new laws. The only way they can do that is if the Republican members are willing to reach across the aisle, even when they don't have to, to engage their Democratic colleagues in the process of drafting legislation and directing the future of this state. We absolutely have to stop saying that the other side is wrong, simply because they are on the other side. And if Republican members are truly interested in representing the people of this state, they have a duty to respond to legitimate concerns about their tactics and their proposed policies, to put their policies forward and open them up to public criticism and then defend and justify them, and perhaps even modify them so that they are more reflective of the views of the entire state.
Finally, if you are mad as hell about what went down this week in Raleigh, its time to get involved and stay engaged. Many members of the general assembly are likely to be up for election this year in special elections ordered by the court. Contact your local Democratic Party and sign-up to volunteer. Consider running for office or encourage a friend or neighbor to run. Ladies, if you've ever given even a passing thought to running, contact Lillian's List and attend one of their upcoming trainings. Use NC Megaphone to email legislators about issues important to you. Better yet, figure out who your individual representative is and email only their office. Representatives are far more responsive to emails sent only to their office than to emails sent to all 170 members. Even though its frustrating and you may feel ignored or discounted, its important to keep making your voice heard. The day we stop believing democracy can work is the day is lose it.
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Saturday, December 17, 2016
Wednesday, April 1, 2015
Abortion. There, I said it.
Abortion is a dirty word. It simply isn't mentioned in polite company. Quite frequently it isn't mentioned in impolite company! Well, I'm not ashamed to let that one little word and all of the emotional baggage and vitriol that comes along with it slip out of my fingers and onto the page. Every woman in this country has the right to an abortion if she wants one. There, I said it.
This week four representatives in the North Carolina House introduced legislation to further restrict access to abortion services. I read the text of the bill sitting at my desk and fought back tears. This evening, on the comfort of my porch, I wept. I wept for the women who will die if this bill passes, for the women whose already painfully difficult decisions will be made worse by a group of men who cannot begin to fathom what it feels like to be the person responsible for the monumental and life-altering decision of whether or not to bring new life into this world. I remembered having to make that decision and I wept for my fourteen year old self.
Changes proposed by the bill include:
These restrictions, while pushed in the name of increasing the safety of women seeking the procedures, actually have the opposite effect. Limiting the number of facilities and physicians who can perform abortion or medically induced miscarriage only serves to limit women's access to medically safe abortion services and increases the likelihood that these women will seek out unsafe abortions or attempt them on their own, endangering their own lives and future fertility. Making abortions harder to obtain does not make them safer.
I noticed as I read through the bill today that the "counseling" requirements remain unchanged. I hadn't had cause to read those counseling requirements until today. I was struck by the fact that they include a provision that the physician must tell the woman that "medical assistance benefits may be available for prenatal care, childbirth and neonatal care" and that "public assistance programs...may or may not be available as benefits under the federal and state assistance programs," and that "the father is liable to assist in the support of the child." All of these required statements seem to be intended to relieve the woman of the notion that she will ultimately be financially responsible for the rearing of her child and to impress upon her the fact that government resources will be made available to her if she only chooses to give her child life and that the child's father will be made to provide for it. Horsefeathers. The intent of these proscribed statements is simply to make a woman question whether her reasons for seeking an abortion are meritorious. They do not seek to improve the health or well-being of the mother or the fetus, nor do they serve to provide for the long-term well-being of either of them. They serve only to guilt her into changing her mind.
Last year the North Carolina General Assembly voted to lower the income guidelines for the state's medicaid program which provides "prenatal, childbirth and neonatal care." Currently, in order to qualify for medical assistance, a single pregnant woman must earn less than $23,000 per year, $2,000 per month. A woman earning $25,000 per year would not qualify for Medicaid services and the cost of her prenatal care and delivery is likely to exceed her entire annual salary. It is the height of hypocrisy for the legislature to impose upon a doctor a mandated script intended to pressure a woman into deciding to keep her child while at the same time voting to restrict the resources that provide for that care. The same rule applies to the legislature's willingness to provide for the child you are encouraging her to bring into the world. How dare you claim that a woman is entitled to federal benefits as a means of inducing her to give birth to a child she may not be able to afford to care for while at the same time denying federal dollars to expand medicaid, cutting funding for child care services and failing to invest in affordable housing initiatives. And, until you are ready to take steps to improve a child support enforcement system that everyone knows is broken, don't tell a woman that the child's father is going to be made to contribute to the cost of care.
This week four representatives in the North Carolina House introduced legislation to further restrict access to abortion services. I read the text of the bill sitting at my desk and fought back tears. This evening, on the comfort of my porch, I wept. I wept for the women who will die if this bill passes, for the women whose already painfully difficult decisions will be made worse by a group of men who cannot begin to fathom what it feels like to be the person responsible for the monumental and life-altering decision of whether or not to bring new life into this world. I remembered having to make that decision and I wept for my fourteen year old self.
Changes proposed by the bill include:
- Increasing the mandatory waiting period from 24 hours to 72 hours
- Requiring procedures to be performed by a certified OB/GYN and prohibiting other physicians from performing them
- Prohibiting NC Universities from teaching physicians how to safely perform abortions.
- Prohibiting two of the best hospitals in the southeast from performing abortions at all
- Requiring physicians to report data, including in some cases an ultrasound image, to the NC Department of Health for every abortion performed
These restrictions, while pushed in the name of increasing the safety of women seeking the procedures, actually have the opposite effect. Limiting the number of facilities and physicians who can perform abortion or medically induced miscarriage only serves to limit women's access to medically safe abortion services and increases the likelihood that these women will seek out unsafe abortions or attempt them on their own, endangering their own lives and future fertility. Making abortions harder to obtain does not make them safer.
I noticed as I read through the bill today that the "counseling" requirements remain unchanged. I hadn't had cause to read those counseling requirements until today. I was struck by the fact that they include a provision that the physician must tell the woman that "medical assistance benefits may be available for prenatal care, childbirth and neonatal care" and that "public assistance programs...may or may not be available as benefits under the federal and state assistance programs," and that "the father is liable to assist in the support of the child." All of these required statements seem to be intended to relieve the woman of the notion that she will ultimately be financially responsible for the rearing of her child and to impress upon her the fact that government resources will be made available to her if she only chooses to give her child life and that the child's father will be made to provide for it. Horsefeathers. The intent of these proscribed statements is simply to make a woman question whether her reasons for seeking an abortion are meritorious. They do not seek to improve the health or well-being of the mother or the fetus, nor do they serve to provide for the long-term well-being of either of them. They serve only to guilt her into changing her mind.
Last year the North Carolina General Assembly voted to lower the income guidelines for the state's medicaid program which provides "prenatal, childbirth and neonatal care." Currently, in order to qualify for medical assistance, a single pregnant woman must earn less than $23,000 per year, $2,000 per month. A woman earning $25,000 per year would not qualify for Medicaid services and the cost of her prenatal care and delivery is likely to exceed her entire annual salary. It is the height of hypocrisy for the legislature to impose upon a doctor a mandated script intended to pressure a woman into deciding to keep her child while at the same time voting to restrict the resources that provide for that care. The same rule applies to the legislature's willingness to provide for the child you are encouraging her to bring into the world. How dare you claim that a woman is entitled to federal benefits as a means of inducing her to give birth to a child she may not be able to afford to care for while at the same time denying federal dollars to expand medicaid, cutting funding for child care services and failing to invest in affordable housing initiatives. And, until you are ready to take steps to improve a child support enforcement system that everyone knows is broken, don't tell a woman that the child's father is going to be made to contribute to the cost of care.
Our legislators, in their exceeding wisdom, also introduced this week a bill to limit sex education in the state to strictly abstinence only. The bill would prohibit the education of teenage boys and girls about the efficacy of all forms of birth control, including Plan B and IUDs, two extremely effective and safe methods of preventing pregnancy which have been deemed abortifacents by those on the religious right who seek only to motivate their base for political gain and care very little about the health or wellbeing of women and girls.
There seems to be a movement on the right to force impoverished women to have children they don't want so that they can then hold those same women up as examples of the greedy culture of poverty that wants to live off of the state so that they can vote in further cuts to social programs. I simply cannot understand the thought process that leads one to believe that you should restrict access to birth control and make it harder to afford, limit access to abortions, and then chastise women who seek federal or state financial assistance to raise children they didn't want to have in the first place. On what planet does this train of thought make sense?
You don't have to like abortions. You can believe with all of your might that the person seeking an abortion or performing it is going to burn in hell for all eternity. That is your right. But you do not have the right to prevent a woman from deciding that abortion is the best option available to her. You don't have the right to tell a rape victim that she must bear and rear the child of her rapist. You don't have the right to tell a fourteen year old girl that she must carry a child to term. You don't have the right to tell a woman who has been told her child stands a 99% chance of being born brain-dead that she must bring that child, doomed to a terribly short life filled with suffering, into the world against her own best judgment. You don't have the right to tell any woman that she must become a mother even if her child was conceived in a loving relationship and both parents can afford to provide care. You do not have the right to tell a woman to become a parent. You simply do not have the right.
The hardest thing for me in reading the proposed legislation is the realization that the authors have such an inability to feel compassion or empathy for the women whose lives will be affected. These are real women undergoing serious emotion duress, struggling with a complex decision that you members of our society who possess penises instead of wombs cannot possibly begin to fathom.
If you believe that there is no circumstance which justifies a woman seeking an abortion, that's fine. You are entitled to your belief. But put your powers to use in the service of good, of God. Offer your time and money and energy in counsel and service to young mothers who need it. Find compassion. Buy groceries. Pay for a car repair. Fund child care programs. Don't use those same resources making women less safe.
I grieve for you, my sisters, who will suffer the burden of compensating for these foolhardy legislative actions, and I promise you that I will do everything in my power to make sure that you have access to safe, affordable abortion services, even if that means I have to drive across the state myself to pick you up, feed and house you. I sure hope it doesn't come to that.
The text of the full bill can be found here. If you are passionate about this issue, I urge you to call or e-mail your legislator. You can find their contact information here.
You don't have to like abortions. You can believe with all of your might that the person seeking an abortion or performing it is going to burn in hell for all eternity. That is your right. But you do not have the right to prevent a woman from deciding that abortion is the best option available to her. You don't have the right to tell a rape victim that she must bear and rear the child of her rapist. You don't have the right to tell a fourteen year old girl that she must carry a child to term. You don't have the right to tell a woman who has been told her child stands a 99% chance of being born brain-dead that she must bring that child, doomed to a terribly short life filled with suffering, into the world against her own best judgment. You don't have the right to tell any woman that she must become a mother even if her child was conceived in a loving relationship and both parents can afford to provide care. You do not have the right to tell a woman to become a parent. You simply do not have the right.
The hardest thing for me in reading the proposed legislation is the realization that the authors have such an inability to feel compassion or empathy for the women whose lives will be affected. These are real women undergoing serious emotion duress, struggling with a complex decision that you members of our society who possess penises instead of wombs cannot possibly begin to fathom.
If you believe that there is no circumstance which justifies a woman seeking an abortion, that's fine. You are entitled to your belief. But put your powers to use in the service of good, of God. Offer your time and money and energy in counsel and service to young mothers who need it. Find compassion. Buy groceries. Pay for a car repair. Fund child care programs. Don't use those same resources making women less safe.
I grieve for you, my sisters, who will suffer the burden of compensating for these foolhardy legislative actions, and I promise you that I will do everything in my power to make sure that you have access to safe, affordable abortion services, even if that means I have to drive across the state myself to pick you up, feed and house you. I sure hope it doesn't come to that.
The text of the full bill can be found here. If you are passionate about this issue, I urge you to call or e-mail your legislator. You can find their contact information here.
Monday, September 2, 2013
From the tiniest voice, "Help! Help!"
I don't consider myself to be a radical. I don't think that my values, while more liberal than some of my friends, are so far to the left that people think, "Wow, look at that wacko. There she goes spouting off her crazy talk again." In fact, I'd like to think that I'm pretty middle of the road.
I think we need welfare reform. The current system does allow some abuses to happen, although they are not nearly as prevalent as the right-wing media would have you believe. Why is it that we still have more than 20 different kinds of "welfare" (think food stamps, cash assistance, social security, disability, Section 8 housing, Medicaid, WIC, daycare vouchers, tax credits, etc.) administered by a bakers dozen of government agencies, all with different income requirements? Why do we require every needy family to meet with administrators from each of these separate agencies to apply and then recertify for benefits every year, or multiple times a year in many cases? Why can't we simplify this process? It wouldn't be hard to create a singular federal form to apply for government benefits, similar to the way the FAFSA allows you to apply for both Federal and State education assistance, to apply for all available government assistance programs. One application should link you with all of the programs for which you qualify. And then, shudder to think, we could assign actual social workers who could help actually lift families out of poverty!
I think we need tax reform. If my congressman can't fill out his taxes without the assistance of a paid professional, the code needs to be simplified. One of the most interesting things I learned on my recent trip abroad is that filing taxes in France takes all of about 90 seconds. The income data is electronically submitted by employers. Taxpayers log on to an online system, answer a few questions, confirm the information submitted by their employer and then, press send. That's it. Done. I want that.
I want women to make their own health care decisions. Whether you agree with their decision or not, it is theirs to make. Whether or not you choose to use birth control, it is their decision to make, not yours. You certainly shouldn't have to resort to back-room political side-stepping to restrict women's access to abortions. In case you haven't ever read anything, ever, it is damn near impossible to force a women who is opposed to giving birth, to give birth, even if that resistance means that she dies in the process of seeking out a dirty, back-room abortion. Conversely, if you give women unfettered access to birth control and education, the number of abortions decrease substantially, go figure.
I think we should legalize marijuana and end the costly and unjust war on drugs. I don't smoke pot, but the people I know who do, aren't criminals and I prefer that my tax dollars not be spent housing and feeding them, when they are perfectly capable of doing that themselves.
I think we should scale way, way, way, way, way, way, way, way back on the amount of money we spend on the NSA, CIA, FBI, Army, Navy, Airforce, Marines, Homeland Security, etc, etc, etc. The truth is, we are pretty much the safest and most over-prepared country on the face of the earth. Most of the money we force down the throat of this plethora of government agencies serves only to line the pockets of shareholders in major companies supporting the war machine. If you believe in small government, lets start the shrinking process here.
I think we need to reform the way we provide subsidies to big Pharma, big Agro, and big Oil. If you gross more than $1 Billion a year, you don't need a government subsidy...for anything. Can I get a' Amen!?
I think we need to increase mandatory paid maternity leave, require paid paternity leave, and pay for pre-k for working single moms and families with two working parents. At some point, we need to recognize that there is value in providing care. Just because it's "women's work" doesn't mean we should continue to devalue it. If we valued child-rearing the same way we valued "stock-rearing," this nation would be a far, far better place to live.
I think we can find the funding to pay elementary school teachers at least as much as I pay my plumber. Lord knows they put up with just as much shit. And, if our economy has evolved so that nearly every job in the workforce requires an advanced degree, we should pay for 2-4 year college educations for everyone and ensure that our entire workforce doesn't start working with $50,000 in debt before they ever purchase a house or a car or have a baby or a major medical procedure.
While we're at it, we ought to provide universal health care. Doing so will create thousands of new jobs, and stop the hemorrhaging of money from the working class into the pockets of the health insurance industry. Obamacare is crap. The private health insurance industry has done absolutely nothing to control costs and the entire system is designed to funnel even more money from the working, middle-class in this country into the pockets of the rich and further widen the expanse that exists between the classes.
I think we should provide an exemption so that teenagers can be paid a lower minimum wage than working adults. If you, as an adult, work full-time at McDonald's or Wal-Mart to support your family, you should gross more than $1,055 a month and my tax dollars shouldn't have to pay for your food. You should be paid an actual living wage for laboring 40 hours a week. But, if you are a 16 year old teenager living at home with your parents, I'm sorry, but I think you can scrape by on $5.00 an hour instead of $7.00. Seriously, it's not gonna kill you.
While we're talking about wages, how about if we stop subsidizing billion dollar profits for companies who pay their workforce next to nothing. If 20% of your workforce qualifies for "entitlement" programs because you keep their wages so low, your company should pay a hefty tax penalty to cover the cost of those programs.
I think we should expand the earned income credit (the exact opposite of what was done in North Carolina this year when the state legislature abolished the earned income tax credit) and pay it to workers weekly instead of paying it out at the end of the year in one lump sum. Give people money to live on, money to support their families, to buy groceries and pay their electric bill instead of vacation money or tattoo money or flat-screen-tv-money.
Am I spouting off crazy talk? Have I spewed gross inaccuracies that are begging for correction? If so, please enlighten me with your comments so that I can reconssider my positions. Whether you agree with every point I make or not, surely you can agree that I do not spout off from some uninformed, entrenched, ideological viewpoint. These are well-reasoned arguments that, according to the current political paradigm, should not be allowed to all occupy the same brain. Most people I know do not easily fit into a solidly "conservative" or "liberal" box, which is itself a major national problem that we must someday address. Not that we need to all fit more nicely into the two available boxes, but that we should have far more boxes to choose from.
There are many, many topics I have not covered here, like the abolition of the estate tax in North Carolina, the inability of the US Congress to reach an agreement about imigration reform, civil rights of the LGBT community, the wholesale seizure of public water assets for the sole purpose of later privatizing the system, large scale environmental cover-ups to support fracking, etc. There seem to be so many directions to which I can shift my focus that I cannot narrow it down and write about just one thing. There are so many public misinformation campaigns going at once. There are so many problems to solve. There is so much injustice, and I am, after all, just one person. One person, with a very tiny voice, and a family and a job and very little time for protesting, or calling representatives, or writing nasty letters. I sure hope someone hears this tiny little voice, yelling out, like the Mayor to Horton, and hoping that someone hears us, down here in a tiny small town in a rural southern state, yelling, "Help, Help!"
Institutional Failures
The world's major religions share many important teachings, the most important of which is that we should give to the poor. Jesus, Buddha. Zoroastra and Ghandi all advocated living a simple life with few physical possessions and giving all that one did not need for survival to others. None of them required that we first evaluate the merit or virtue of the recipient. None of the scriptures say that we should give to the poor, but only if they are able to first demonstrate that they are really working hard to pull themselves up by their own bootstraps.
In the US, we responded to these commandments by establishing a social safety net in the form of Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, SNAP (Food Stamps), Public Housing & Section 8 rental assistance, unemployment and TANF (welfare). We created these programs to support the needy because we consider ourselves to be a moral society that does not want to see our brethren suffer and die in a land of plenty and excess.
The problem is that these systems, as currently designed, disincentivize work and increased wages. This only feeds the public perception that the poor are lazy and undeserving of our assistance. In truth, there are very few people who desire to subsist only on handouts from the government. This is not a pleasant way to live. But, the programs are designed by people who have never had to use them, by bureaucrats who fail to see how one program interacts with another.
The poor, especially the working poor, must always work to keep their earnings below the levels set by the various programs they collect so that their benefits will continue, so that they do not work themselves further into poverty. If a person is physically disabled and in desperate need of Medicaid coverage, he must apply for Social Security Disability and, once receiving that benefit, must keep his earnings less than about $500 a month. Failure to do so could mean a complete loss of lifesaving medical care. But, what if this person wants to work, at a desk, using a brain that is not so disabled? Our system doesn't allow for that, and that is a travesty.
A working single mother offered a $.50 raise by her employer must be cognizant of the fact that her raise is going to increase her bring-home pay by less than $75.00 per month, but could result in a combined reduction of more than $100 a month in her non-cash benefits. So, she is likely to refuse a raise and remain on government programs so that she doesn't have to figure out how to make dinner with $25.00 less in groceries. This is not her fault. This is an institutional failure, a failure of the programs' designers to see how the programs are utilized in the real world.
The Earned Income Tax Credit is one of the most targeted and beneficial of our safety net programs. It is so unfortunate that NC's state legislature decided to do away with this program this year instead of finding a way for it to function in a more useful manner. It is unfortunate that our national leaders decided years ago to do away with the Advanced Earned Income Credit which allowed a wage-earner to choose to receive the tax refund incrementally over the course of the year. This again represents a failure on the part of our leadership to recognize what makes a difference for people in the real world or the way one program affects another. Currently, families can receive as much as $7,000 in EITC tax refund. This money, when added to an annual salary of $20,000 could mean a substantial increase in the family's quality of life, except that it is given in one lump sum instead of distributed over the course of the year. Not only does this fail to account for the gigantic exercise in self control you are asking of a person who has struggled for a year to make ends meet, choosing to buy bread and milk instead of paying an electric bill, who now has 4-5 months worth of take-home pay sitting in a bank account, but it also fails to account for the fact that having such a large sum of money in the bank is likely going to mean that he is suddenly disqualified from receiving any other public benefits until the money is spent. He is forced to spend this money on large purchases in a short time which does not overall increase his family's quality of life for the coming year. Again, this is not his fault, it is a failure of the system.
It doesn't have to be this way. The system could be fixed. We could take a moment and put some real thought into the design of our safety net. We could have a conversation about what we expect our safety net to provide for people. What is its purpose? What are we trying to accomplish? We could find a way to incentivize work and stop penalizing people for earning a higher wage. We could find a way to wean people off of the safety net programs without decreasing their quality of life in the process. We could streamline the administration of programs so that there is less paperwork and more person-to-person social work. We could pay a social worker to give a family the resources that will lift them out of poverty. We could help them to find those elusive bootstraps.
"If anyone has material possessions and sees his brother in need but has no pity on him, how can the love of God be in him? Dear children, let us not love with words or tongue but with actions and in truth." I John 3:17-18 (Christianity)
The problem is that these systems, as currently designed, disincentivize work and increased wages. This only feeds the public perception that the poor are lazy and undeserving of our assistance. In truth, there are very few people who desire to subsist only on handouts from the government. This is not a pleasant way to live. But, the programs are designed by people who have never had to use them, by bureaucrats who fail to see how one program interacts with another.
The poor, especially the working poor, must always work to keep their earnings below the levels set by the various programs they collect so that their benefits will continue, so that they do not work themselves further into poverty. If a person is physically disabled and in desperate need of Medicaid coverage, he must apply for Social Security Disability and, once receiving that benefit, must keep his earnings less than about $500 a month. Failure to do so could mean a complete loss of lifesaving medical care. But, what if this person wants to work, at a desk, using a brain that is not so disabled? Our system doesn't allow for that, and that is a travesty.
A working single mother offered a $.50 raise by her employer must be cognizant of the fact that her raise is going to increase her bring-home pay by less than $75.00 per month, but could result in a combined reduction of more than $100 a month in her non-cash benefits. So, she is likely to refuse a raise and remain on government programs so that she doesn't have to figure out how to make dinner with $25.00 less in groceries. This is not her fault. This is an institutional failure, a failure of the programs' designers to see how the programs are utilized in the real world.
The Earned Income Tax Credit is one of the most targeted and beneficial of our safety net programs. It is so unfortunate that NC's state legislature decided to do away with this program this year instead of finding a way for it to function in a more useful manner. It is unfortunate that our national leaders decided years ago to do away with the Advanced Earned Income Credit which allowed a wage-earner to choose to receive the tax refund incrementally over the course of the year. This again represents a failure on the part of our leadership to recognize what makes a difference for people in the real world or the way one program affects another. Currently, families can receive as much as $7,000 in EITC tax refund. This money, when added to an annual salary of $20,000 could mean a substantial increase in the family's quality of life, except that it is given in one lump sum instead of distributed over the course of the year. Not only does this fail to account for the gigantic exercise in self control you are asking of a person who has struggled for a year to make ends meet, choosing to buy bread and milk instead of paying an electric bill, who now has 4-5 months worth of take-home pay sitting in a bank account, but it also fails to account for the fact that having such a large sum of money in the bank is likely going to mean that he is suddenly disqualified from receiving any other public benefits until the money is spent. He is forced to spend this money on large purchases in a short time which does not overall increase his family's quality of life for the coming year. Again, this is not his fault, it is a failure of the system.
It doesn't have to be this way. The system could be fixed. We could take a moment and put some real thought into the design of our safety net. We could have a conversation about what we expect our safety net to provide for people. What is its purpose? What are we trying to accomplish? We could find a way to incentivize work and stop penalizing people for earning a higher wage. We could find a way to wean people off of the safety net programs without decreasing their quality of life in the process. We could streamline the administration of programs so that there is less paperwork and more person-to-person social work. We could pay a social worker to give a family the resources that will lift them out of poverty. We could help them to find those elusive bootstraps.
"If anyone has material possessions and sees his brother in need but has no pity on him, how can the love of God be in him? Dear children, let us not love with words or tongue but with actions and in truth." I John 3:17-18 (Christianity)
"There will always be poor people in the land. Therefore I command you to be openhanded toward your brothers and toward the poor and needy in your land." Deuteronomy 15:11 (Judaism)
"Do you know who really rejects the faith? That is the one who mistreats the orphans. And does not advocate the feeding of the poor." Quran 107:1-7 (Islam)
"One may amass wealth with hundreds of hands but one should also distribute it with thousands of hands. If someone keeps all that he accumulates for himself and does not give it to others the hoarded wealth will eventually prove to be the cause of ruin." Atharva Veda 3: 24-25 (Hinduism)
"Possessions are ephemeral and essenceless
Know this and give them generously to monks,
To brahmins, to the poor, and to your friends:
Beyond there is no greater friend than gift." Bhikshuni Thubten Chodron, from 'How to Free Your Mind: Tara the Liberator' (Buddhismn)
Know this and give them generously to monks,
To brahmins, to the poor, and to your friends:
Beyond there is no greater friend than gift." Bhikshuni Thubten Chodron, from 'How to Free Your Mind: Tara the Liberator' (Buddhismn)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)